On September 28, 2026, The Florida Trib published a story by reporter Kate Payne that every detective, supervisor, and police executive in this country should read. It describes how a Jacksonville father of two, identified only as “Nick,” was handcuffed at his workplace in May 2025 and charged with trying to entice a 13-year-old girl over the internet. He had done nothing of the kind. The arrest grew out of a multi-agency sting called Operation Rescue Our Children. In an operation like this, undercover officers pose online as children to identify adults seeking to exploit them. That work is necessary and honorable. But in Nick’s case, the investigation stopped at the point where it should have started.
The facts as reported are straightforward. A man named Richard Steven Cook, who had already been convicted of the same type of offense, logged on to a dating app called Skout under the name “Steven.” He carried on an explicit conversation with an undercover officer and sent her two photographs. The photographs were not of Cook. They were of Nick, a former friend, and they had apparently been taken from Nick’s Facebook page. Investigators ran the images through facial recognition, which is software that measures the features of a face and compares them against databases of mugshots and driver’s license photos. The software returned Nick’s name, and six days after the chat ended, deputies arrested him.
I want to be precise about what went wrong, because it is easy to blame the technology. The software did exactly what it was designed to do. It correctly identified the man in the photographs. The failure was that no one asked the next question, the one every experienced investigator is trained to ask: who sent the photographs? Knowing who appears in an image is not the same as knowing who is holding the phone. As Professor Andrew Ferguson of George Washington University told the Trib, “This is not a bad technology story. This is a bad policing story.”
The answer to that second question was readily available. A subpoena for the account’s subscriber information would have shown that it was tied to the same email address Cook had used when he was arrested in 2018. The account’s own profile picture showed a different man, with different hair, from the man in the photographs. Investigators did issue those subpoenas, but they did so the day after they arrested Nick. They had the order of the steps reversed: arrest first, investigate second.
Worse still, when Nick was brought into the interview room, he gave the detectives the real suspect. He told them the profile photo was Cook’s, that Cook had been arrested before for the same offense, and that the two men were still connected on Facebook. All of this could have been verified in minutes. Instead, he spent the night in jail because a judge had already signed a warrant. In my years as a homicide detective and later in Internal Affairs and as deputy commander of all investigative functions, I learned that a signed warrant does not end an investigator’s obligation to think. Probable cause is not a box you check once. When credible exculpatory information comes to light, the detective has a duty to stop, verify, and bring it forward.
The consequences for this family were severe. A court barred Nick from any contact with his two young daughters, one of them only seven months old, for a month and a half. He lived away from his own home for nearly three months, wore an ankle monitor at his own expense, and lost his income. The family estimates the ordeal cost them about $45,000. Charges were dropped only after Cook confessed in July 2025. Even then, the court-ordered expungement, the legal process of erasing an arrest record, was not carried out for more than a year. The family says the promises made to them afterward were not kept.
There is a part of this story that should concern every law enforcement professional, regardless of their views on technology. While the agency spent its time and resources prosecuting the wrong man, a person with a documented history of targeting children remained free for roughly five more months. Cook was not taken into custody until October 17, 2025. A wrongful arrest is never only a civil liberties problem. It is also a public safety failure, because every hour spent on the wrong suspect is an hour the right one is not being pursued.
The Trib also reports that the timing of Nick’s arrest coincided with a press conference announcing the results of the operation. I have stood behind those podiums, and I understand the pressure to show results. But leaders must recognize when the demand for numbers begins to outrun the discipline of the investigation. Nothing about the facts of this case required an arrest that day.
The Jacksonville Sheriff’s Office did not respond to the Trib’s questions, so we have only one side of the account. Even so, the lessons are clear and they are not new. Facial recognition should be treated the way we have always treated a fingerprint candidate list from the Automated Fingerprint Identification System, commonly known as AFIS. It is a starting point that must be confirmed by independent evidence before anyone is placed in handcuffs. The rules governing FACESNXT, the database used by Florida agencies, already say exactly that. Sheriff T.K. Waters said much the same thing publicly after an earlier wrongful arrest involving his agency. The problem here was not the absence of a policy. It was the absence of follow-through.
Artificial intelligence will become an ever larger part of how we investigate crime, and in the right hands it will help us solve cases we could not solve before. But technology does not relieve us of the obligation to do the work. The tools have changed since I started on midnight patrol in the early 1980s, but the fundamentals of a good investigation have not. Corroborate your lead, test your assumptions, and listen when the person in front of you tells you that you have the wrong man. Our communities are entitled to expect nothing less.
Source: Kate Payne, “How AI-powered bungling by Florida cops cost a father his freedom and $45,000,” The Florida Trib, September 28, 2026.
Authored by David A. Rivero of Investigations101 LLC, November 2026, www.Investigations101.com